Main Content

94 Judith’s Fancy CO, St. Croix, (MLS# 26-868)

94 Judith's Fancy CO, St. Croix,

$1,089,000
Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 4 Baths: 4 Square Footage: 3,895 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 42,689 Status: Active
Current Price: $1,089,000 List Date: 5/02/2026 Last Modified: 5/14/2026

Description

Beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 4-bath home located on a quiet, tucked-away road within the neighborhood of Judith's Fancy. Thoughtfully repositioned as the sellers prepare for a professional work-related relocation, this upgraded island residence presents an exceptional opportunity offering privacy, energy efficiency, and flexible indoor-outdoor living. The property is competitively positioned for buyers seeking a move-in-ready home that combines energy resilience, functionality, and comfortable island living within one of St. Croix's well-known residential neighborhoods. Designed in a desirable horseshoe layout, the home captures abundant natural light and island breezes, with the private swimming pool serving as the focal point of the outdoor living experience.

Supplements: A standout feature of the property is its thoughtfully integrated energy infrastructure, including solar panels, two owned Tesla battery storage systems with no financing, and a backup generator. Together, these systems support greater energy independence, operational continuity during outages, and long-term efficiency--an increasingly valuable asset for island living. The property also includes a Starlink system, providing reliable high-speed internet connectivity. The main residence features three bedrooms and two baths surrounding an open-concept living, dining, and kitchen area that serves as the heart of the home--ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. The fourth bedroom and bath are privately positioned with direct access to the pool deck and include a sink and refrigerator with room for a future kitchenette, making the space ideal for guests, extended stays, or flexible living arrangements. A fourth full bathroom is also conveniently located near the pool area for easy outdoor access. Outdoor living is a true highlight, featuring a wrap-around deck, shaded trellis area, and dedicated outdoor-access bathroom. The seamless connection between the kitchen, great room, and exterior entertaining spaces creates an effortless flow for gatherings and island living. The centrally positioned kitchen offers ample cabinetry, generous counterspace, functional island workspace, a Frigidaire refrigerator, and a Thor multi-burner gas stove. Multiple indoor and outdoor gathering areas provide a warm and inviting atmosphere suited for both entertaining and comfortable daily living. Additional infrastructure includes a well, (well condition is unknown, conveyed AS-IS, WHERE-IS), a 500-gallon propane tank, whole-house water filtration system, and a recently cleaned and resealed cistern. An added bonus is a conceptual floor plan for a potential separate two-story structure at the rear of the property, envisioned to include a living suite and ground-floor studio space--ideal for future guest accommodations, creative workspace, wellness use, or expansion potential, subject to approvals. Located within Judith's Fancy, residents enjoy established surroundings, steady breezes, low-traffic streets, and convenient access to shopping, dining, schools, and essential services. This home offers a rare blend of space, privacy, energy efficiency, and comfortable island living in a well-established residential setting. Private showings are available by appointment.

More Information MLS# 26-868

LocationArea

Estate: Judith's Fancy CO Postal Code: 00820 Geo Lat: 17.772834 Geo Lon: -64.743697 Directions: Enter at Judith's Fancy guard gate, make first right on to Jefferson Way, then first left on to Arawak Road. Continue straight. House is 7th house on the left.

Contract Information

List Price: $1,089,000 Current Price: $1,089,000 Begin Date: 2026-04-27

General Property Description

Realtor.COM Type: Residential - Single Family Lot Acres: 0.98 Approx Total Main House: 3895 Approx Total Property SqFt: 3895 Total Bedrooms: 4 Number of Bedrooms - Main House: 4 Total Bathrooms: 4 Sub Type: Residential - Single Taxes: 1581.89 Tax Year: 2026 Year Built: 1988 Furnished: Negotiable Water Front: No Pool: Yes Zoning: R-1 Stamp Tax: Negotiable

Status Change Info

Status: Active

Miscellaneous

PWD#: 753-H

Exterior

Landscape: Lush Off Street Parking: Yes

Cistern

Approx. Cistern Size: 22000

Appliance

Air Conditioning: Split

Main House

Approx Interior SqFt - Main House: 2295 Approx Exterior SqFt - Main House: 1600

Fees

Association Fee Amount: 1300 Association Fee Frequency: Annually

Property Features

View: Neighborhood Amenities: Deck; Filtration System Flooring: Vinyl Upper Baths: Shower Construction: Concrete Block Roof: Fluid Applied Water Source: Cistern Sewer: Septic Road: Asphalt Terrain: Low/Flat Security: Gate; Guard Fees: Association Fee

Room Information

Bathroom Length: 11.03 Length: 11.03 Width: 5.24 Area: 57.80 Width: 5.24 Area: 57.80 Bathroom Length: 7.20 Length: 7.20 Width: 5.20 Area: 37.44 Width: 5.20 Area: 37.44 Bathroom Bedroom 2 Length: 14.51 Length: 14.51 Width: 14.08 Area: 204.30 Width: 14.08 Area: 204.30 Bedroom 3 Length: 14.52 Length: 14.52 Width: 11.29 Area: 163.93 Width: 11.29 Area: 163.93 Bedroom 4 Length: 11.03 Length: 11.03 Width: 13.05 Area: 143.94 Width: 13.05 Area: 143.94 Dining Room Length: 10.46 Length: 10.46 Width: 14.88 Area: 155.64 Width: 14.88 Area: 155.64 Kitchen Length: 14.66 Length: 14.66 Width: 15.52 Area: 227.52 Width: 15.52 Area: 227.52 Living Room Length: 19.15 Length: 19.15 Width: 14.94 Area: 286.10 Width: 14.94 Area: 286.10 Master Bedroom
Listing Office: Welcome Home Realty
Office Phone: 323-382-9606
Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Skip to content